Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Franklin O'Kanu's avatar

Dr. Stephens! Pleasure to meet another HBCU alumn! I agree 100% that BLM is only utilized when it’s helping with their agenda.

If only our people will wake up and realize the culture warfare at play: https://unorthodoxy.substack.com/p/the-culture-warfare-on-the-african

Expand full comment
Fabius Minarchus's avatar

In fairness to the Democrats, they did try a massive crackdown on crime back in the Clinton era, and Joe Biden was one of the architects of the crackdown. Then the Black prison population exploded to horrifying levels. Frankly, it surprised me that it took so long for something like BLM to arise.

The challenging question is how to cut the crime rate in poor urban Black communities without horrendous levels of incarceration. The subject is a huge one, requiring multiple posts to cover. So I'll just drop some hints and links here in this comment.

Obviously, we need to reduce the marriage penalty for getting welfare and/or get more people off welfare. To do the latter humanely, we need to raise the *market* minimum wage and/or have a citizen dividend so those with limited skills can lead a tolerable life while building up the discipline and experience that comes from working vs. collecting welfare. Simply cutting off welfare checks, as was attempted during the Clinton-Gingrich era resulted in welfare families going from zero to three jobs. This was not family friendly!

Enforcing the national picket line, as Trump attempted to do, would raise the market minimum wage. This would have solved much, but not immediately. (And, by the way, Trump did not go far enough with the tariff aspect of the national picket line. https://rulesforreactionaries.substack.com/p/free-trade-isnt )

We also need to reform those who grew up in broken families in broken neighborhoods. Our current prison system has been scientifically proven to be ineffective in this regard.

Should we raise tariffs up to what we tax domestic labor, there would be "labor shortages." Prisoners could work -- and get paid for it. Instead of dehumanizing men by cramming them into cages with nothing to do but play power games, they could be learning job skills and discipline, and living a much lower stressed existence: cheap hotel room with barred doors vs. the nightmare prisons we have today. And when they are freed, they would have money saved up so they wouldn't have to resort to crime to survive.

This is a general problem with our justice [sic] system, but thanks to the magic of previous persecutions, there is disparate impact. Until recently, the main racism I have witnessed on the Right was insensitivity to the problems with our penal system. With the January 6th fiasco and the hounding of Trump, the Right is starting to notice the problems.

Where the Right currently rocks is in the area of education reform. School choice isn't too big a deal in wealthy suburban neighborhoods where the schools are filled with the children of families which value education. It's a huge deal for rough neighborhoods. Being academically inclined in certain schools is physically dangerous. Requiring kids from such neighborhoods to go to a super authoritarian KIPP school to escape bullies is cruel.

Our core cities need smaller schools so students don't need gang membership for protection. And we need to replace our envy-producing grading system with a system which celebrates comparative advantage. Fix the first stages of the school to prison pipeline. https://rulesforreactionaries.substack.com/p/rule-5-teach-more-practical-arts

This is an incomplete answer to an important question. But for now I will conclude with the assertion: there is a Right wing way to make Black lives matter.

Expand full comment
32 more comments...

No posts